Skip it for now. It scores 56, well short of the 85 a Keeper needs. The weakest part is the critics: a critic score of 77, 35th of the 38 albums we scored.
Skip for nowWorth itKeeper
Where the 56 comes from
Critics10/40
Critic score 77. A 70 earns nothing and a 98 earns all 40 points.
Audience10/20
Audience score 79. A 60 earns nothing and a 98 earns all 20 points.
Track record15/15
Madonna made it as a sequel to Confessions on a Dance Floor from 2005.
Staying power21/25
It debuted at No. 1 on the Billboard 200 with 134,000 units and at No. 1 in the UK, and topped charts in 17 countries.
10 + 10 + 15 + 21 = 56
Scores used: AOTY critic score 77 from 25 reviews, user score 79 from 6,940 ratings. Numbers checked October 26, 2026. See the main source.
Find it on Amazon. As an Amazon Associate, Keepers earns from qualifying purchases.
One short email when something new makes the list: an album to play, a game to buy, a film to watch, a book to read, tech worth buying, a thing that lasts. Nothing else.
How the score works
Albums, games, films, shows and books
Critics, 40. The published aggregate from Metacritic, OpenCritic, Album of the Year or Rotten Tomatoes. For books, Book Marks grades every major review rave, positive, mixed or pan; we read those as 100, 75, 50 and 25 and take the average. Almost everything reviewed lands between 70 and 98, so a 70 earns nothing and a 98 earns all 40.
Audience, 20. What people who paid for it say, from user scores, Steam reviews and, for books, the Goodreads average times 20. A 60 earns nothing and a 98 earns all 20.
Track record, 15. Whether the people who made it have made things that lasted before. Debuts start lower on purpose.
Staying power, 25. What happens after launch week: chart runs, players who stick around, renewals, sales that keep going, prize shortlists.
A Keeper is our bet on what lasts. Some releases show it right away: the reviews, the players and the people behind them all point the same way, the way they did for Elden Ring. For albums, games, films, shows and books, 85 or above is a Keeper and 75 to 84 is worth your time. Things and tech need 80. We score everything again as time goes by, and a Keeper that fades loses the label. Nobody pays to be here or pays for a score. Every score links to where its numbers came from. Each one has a link to find it on Amazon, and as an Amazon Associate, Keepers earns from qualifying purchases.